No true Scotsmen – or Christians
The “no true Scotsman” fallacy (as it is called) is illustrated like this:
William: No Scotsman wears underwear under his kilt
Angus: Not true! I’m a bonnie Scotsman, and I wear underwear under me kilt!
William: Ach! Then yer nee a true Scotsman! Away with ye!
One who uses this fallacy makes their position beyond critique by [...]
Go to Source
Posted on November 14, 2009 at 11:10 pm by Glenn|Beretta-Online.com · Permalink
In: Contributors, political, theology
In: Contributors, political, theology

